We priced Thanksgiving dinner at three of the largest US grocers. Kroger was the most expensive.
We compared a Thanksgiving dinner at Kroger, Walmart and Aldi on the same day, at stores on the same road.
With Thanksgiving in just a few days, we went shopping. We priced the same 18-item Thanksgiving dinner for 10 at three major grocery chains, Kroger, Walmart and Aldi, on the same day, at stores on the same road.
Kroger was the most expensive by over 15%.
| Kroger | Walmart | Aldi | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regular prices | $87.29 | $75.69 | $71.10 |
| With sale prices | $83.52 | $66.50 | $62.32 |
At regular prices, the Kroger basket cost $11.60 more than Walmart's and $16.19 more than Aldi's, about 23% more. Count each store's sale prices and the gap grows: $17.02 more than Walmart and $21.20 more than Aldi. Kroger's sale prices generally require its loyalty card, while Walmart's Rollbacks and Aldi's Price Drops need no card.
Item by item, Kroger was usually highest
Kroger had the highest price of the three grocers on 16 of the 18 items. The two exceptions were a stalk of celery and a 3-pound bag of onions, where Walmart's regular price was higher. Aldi beat Kroger on all 18.
Three items were the exact same product at all three stores, and still Kroger charged the most for each.
| Item | Kroger | Walmart | Aldi |
|---|---|---|---|
| Butterball whole turkey (16 lb) | $20.48 | $15.52 | $20.32 |
| Pillsbury refrigerated pie crusts (2 ct) | $5.29 | $4.26 | $3.46 |
| King's Hawaiian sweet rolls (12 ct) | $5.00 | $4.52 | $4.72 |
| Total | $30.77 | $24.30 | $28.50 |
Store brands, too
On seven store-brand staples (whole milk, heavy cream, eggs, evaporated milk, butter, frozen peas and frozen green beans), Kroger's own brand cost more than both Walmart's and Aldi's on every single one. Together they came to $17.43 at Kroger, $15.17 at Walmart and $14.69 at Aldi. Kroger's frozen peas even came in a smaller bag: 12 ounces for $1.29, against 16 ounces for $0.98 at Walmart and $0.95 at Aldi.
Before you shop
Families are already stretched this year, and a holiday meal adds up fast. Before you shop for Thanksgiving, compare prices to help save money.
The full receipt
Regular prices, with sale prices in brackets where the store showed one.
| Item | What we bought | Kroger | Walmart | Aldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Turkey | Butterball frozen whole turkey, 16 lb | $20.48 | $15.52 | $20.32 [$12.64] |
| Stuffing | 12 oz (Kroger, Walmart: Pepperidge Farm; Aldi: Chef's Cupboard) | $3.99 [$3.00] | $3.12 [$2.68] | $2.19 |
| Rolls | King's Hawaiian Original, 12 ct | $5.00 [$4.49] | $4.52 | $4.72 [$4.52] |
| Pie crusts | Pillsbury refrigerated, 2 ct | $5.29 [$4.00] | $4.26 [$3.47] | $3.46 |
| Frozen peas | Store brand (Kroger 12 oz; Walmart, Aldi 16 oz) | $1.29 | $0.98 | $0.95 |
| Fresh cranberries | 12 oz (Kroger: Ocean Spray; Walmart, Aldi: unbranded) | $2.99 [$2.50] | $1.98 [$0.76] | $0.75 |
| Carrots | 2 lb bag | $2.29 | $2.26 [$1.97] | $1.99 |
| Celery | 1 stalk | $1.49 | $2.37 [$0.97] | $0.95 |
| Whole milk | Store brand, 1 gal | $3.09 | $3.00 | $2.91 |
| Heavy whipping cream | Store brand, 1 qt | $5.49 [$5.00] | $4.58 | $4.35 |
| Pumpkin pie mix | 30 oz (Kroger, Walmart: Libby's; Aldi: Baker's Corner) | $4.99 | $3.57 | $1.99 |
| Eggs | Store brand, large, 12 ct | $1.79 | $1.67 | $1.66 |
| Evaporated milk | Store brand, 12 oz | $1.19 | $1.00 | $0.95 |
| Butter | Store brand, 1 lb | $3.29 | $2.96 | $2.89 [$1.99] |
| Onions | Yellow, 3 lb bag | $3.39 | $3.88 [$2.00] | $2.39 |
| Boneless ham | 4 lb (see methodology) | $15.96 | $15.08 [$13.40] | $13.96 |
| Russet potatoes | 5 lb bag | $3.99 | $3.96 [$2.47] | $3.69 |
| Frozen green beans | Store brand, 12 oz | $1.29 | $0.98 | $0.98 |
| Total, regular prices | $87.29 | $75.69 | $71.10 | |
| Total, with sale prices | $83.52 | $66.50 | $62.32 | |
Our methodology
Stores and date. We compared the Kroger at 2474 Stringtown Rd., the Walmart Supercenter at 1693 Stringtown Rd. and the Aldi at 2398 Stringtown Rd. in Grove City, Ohio, on the southwest side of Columbus. We checked prices on Nov. 18, 2026, around midday, one week before Thanksgiving. We also priced the same basket at two regional chains nearby, Giant Eagle and Meijer. Both cost more than Kroger at regular prices; with sale prices, Meijer came in below Kroger. These results describe these stores on that day, not every store in each chain.
Where the prices came from. Each store's website, set to that store, signed out. For Kroger and Aldi we used their in-store pricing modes. Walmart's site has no in-store mode, so we used its store-specific online price. Online prices can differ from shelf prices. Several items showed as unavailable or out of stock online, including Walmart's turkey; we used the price the site listed. We saved a screenshot of every price.
The basket. We used the American Farm Bureau Federation's Thanksgiving dinner survey for 10 as the guide: turkey, stuffing, rolls, pie crusts, peas, cranberries, carrots and celery, milk, whipping cream and pumpkin pie mix, plus the Farm Bureau's added items (ham, Russet potatoes and green beans). For its "miscellaneous ingredients" we bought what the stuffing and pie directions call for: eggs, evaporated milk, butter and onions. We left out sweet potatoes because Aldi had none to price.
Shopping-trip rule. For each item we bought the package closest to the Farm Bureau's amount and counted the full package price. Turkey and ham are sold by the pound, so we priced them at 16 pounds and 4 pounds. A few sizes were set to match what Aldi sells, such as a quart of cream, a 16-ounce bag of peas and a 3-pound bag of onions.
Matching products. Where all three stores sold the same product, we used it everywhere. Next, where Kroger and Walmart shared a name brand Aldi doesn't carry (Pepperidge Farm stuffing, Libby's pie mix), we used it at those two and Aldi's own brand at Aldi. Otherwise we used each store's own brand. Kroger sold no store-brand fresh cranberries, so we used Ocean Spray there. For ham, Kroger's is a boneless half ham, while Walmart and Aldi listed only spiral-sliced boneless hams, all priced per pound.
Regular and sale prices. Our headline totals use regular prices. We counted sale prices shown on each site (Kroger's "Sale" prices, Walmart's Rollbacks and Aldi's Price Drops) separately. We left out clip-to-use digital coupons. Kroger offered one on the Butterball turkey, at $0.88 a pound for loyalty members. Even counting it, Kroger's total with sales would be $77.12, still the highest of the three.
Sales tax is not included; Ohio does not tax most groceries.